PROJECT ALDER: COMPLETED TEACHING EXAMPLE Version 1.0 | 16 November 2026 | Vibor Cipan Companion: https://viborc.com/cognitive-biases-intelligence-analysis-mitigation/ FICTIONAL: Project Alder, all records, dates relative to the exercise, and all events below are invented for instruction. There are no real source URLs. This is not an investigation, a measured intervention, or an official form. QUESTION Is Project Alder's new data center already operating at full capacity? Scope defect: "full capacity" was initially undefined. A real assessment must specify the halls, time period, and measure (commissioned halls, available IT power, utilization, or another precisely defined quantity). SOURCE LOG R1 | Operator announcement | F1 | Origin of the opening claim. Describes an opening ceremony; provides no operating-load measurement. Establishes that the operator made an announcement. Does not establish current site-wide full-capacity operation. R2 | Newswire item | F1 | R2 -> R1. Repeats R1; no separate operational observation described. R3 | Industry article | F1 | R3 -> R2 -> R1. Summarizes R2; no separate operational observation described. R4 | Local article | F1 | R4 -> R1. Quotes R1; no site visit or separate interview described. R5 | AI-generated briefing | F1 | R5 -> R2 and R3 -> R1. Its two citations reach the same announcement. Adds no independent observation of the activity relevant to this claim. INITIAL REVISION Unsupported: "Five independent reports confirm full-capacity operation." Supported: The operator announced an opening. The five publications trace the relevant claim to one source family, F1. They do not establish current full-capacity operation. Dependence does not establish that the claim is false. FURTHER FICTIONAL RECORDS R6 | Regulator register | F2 | Separate regulatory record. Describes conditional connection approval. Published scope does not cover actual operating load. Neither its wording nor absence of another entry settles current operation without knowing the register's coverage. R7 | Inspector report | F3 | Separately collected observation. Documents one hall operating during a dated visit. Does not cover every planned hall or establish current site-wide full-capacity operation. ALTERNATIVES - A ceremony occurred while commissioning continued. - Some capacity was operating while other halls remained incomplete. - Full-capacity operation existed but is not established by these records. These are possibilities to examine, not assigned probabilities. Some can coexist; this is not a mutually exclusive probability partition. ASSESSMENT Established within the fictional records: an operator announcement; a conditional regulatory approval; an inspection observing one operating hall. Unresolved: the defined site-wide operating-capacity claim at the relevant time. Judgment: full-capacity operation is not established by the available evidence. Confidence reasons: the reporting chain is explicit; R7 is specific but limited. Reasons for caution: the measure is underspecified; coverage and currency differ. Probability estimate: NOT ESTIMATED. No publication-count confidence formula. WHAT WOULD CHANGE THIS ASSESSMENT Current, independently checkable commissioning or operational records covering the specified halls and measure, with their methods and reporting period. Another publication repeating R1 would not add a new operational observation. REVIEW NOTE All family assignments follow the stipulated fictional record descriptions. Real assignments require inspecting sources; similar wording or a different publisher alone cannot establish dependence or independence.