CLAIM AND SOURCE-INDEPENDENCE WORKSHEET Version 1.0 | 16 November 2026 | Vibor Cipan Companion: https://viborc.com/cognitive-biases-intelligence-analysis-mitigation/ An editorial aid for documenting an assessment. Not an official intelligence form, validated debiasing intervention, or numerical confidence score. Use one copy per claim. Duplicate the SOURCE RECORD block for each source. 1. QUESTION AND SCOPE Exact claim: Entity / location: Relevant time or reporting period: Meaning of key terms and measurement units: Decision this assessment will inform: Assessment date: 2. SOURCE RECORD (repeat as needed) Source ID: Title / author / publisher: URL or other retrievable locator: Publication date / date accessed: Exact passage, page, timestamp, or observation supporting this claim: What the source actually establishes: What it does NOT establish: Earliest traceable origin for this information: Source-family ID (or UNKNOWN): Reporting chain (for example R3 -> R2 -> R1): Independent collection for this claim: YES / NO / UNKNOWN Basis for that independence judgment: Supports / challenges / leaves unanswered which part of the claim: Access, expertise, incentives, methods, and other source limitations: Do not infer independence from different domains, authors, or AI models alone. Do not infer common origin from similar language alone. Keep an unknown trail unknown until there is evidence to resolve it. Independence is claim-specific. 3. ALTERNATIVES AND ASSUMPTIONS Working explanation: Plausible alternative explanation(s): Evidence that distinguishes them: Evidence sought that could challenge the working explanation: Important assumptions: What changes if an assumption is wrong: Missing evidence and limits of the available search: 4. ASSESSMENT What is established: What remains unresolved: Current judgment, within the stated scope: Reasons for confidence in its evidence base: Reasons for caution: Probability estimate IF appropriate, with its basis (otherwise NOT ESTIMATED): Keep event likelihood distinct from confidence in the evidence and reasoning. Do not calculate a confidence percentage by counting publications or families. 5. REVISION AND REVIEW Specific evidence that would change the judgment: Next proportionate check: Reviewer / review date: Unresolved disagreement: Revision history: date | new evidence or reasoning | resulting change Record only material you are entitled to retain or share. Keep sensitive source identities and private research out of public copies of the worksheet.